Chapter 2 National Income Accounting

Introduction

This chapter introduces the fundamental concepts and methods used to measure the aggregate economic activity of a nation, commonly referred to as national income accounting. It distinguishes macroeconomics from microeconomics in this context and sets the stage for understanding how wealth is generated and measured at the country level.

---

Microeconomics Versus Macroeconomics

While microeconomics studies individual economic decisions made by consumers and firms, macroeconomics examines the economy as a whole. Key questions in macroeconomics relate to the overall performance and health of the national economy, focusing on aggregate indicators like national income, unemployment, and inflation.

---

Basic Questions Of Macroeconomics

Central questions in macroeconomics revolve around understanding the sources of a nation's economic wealth and what determines whether countries are rich or poor. Unlike simply possessing natural resources, the key lies in the efficient utilization of resources to generate a continuous flow of production, leading to income and wealth accumulation.

---

Simplification Through Aggregates

Macroeconomics simplifies the analysis of millions of individual transactions by focusing on aggregate variables. Instead of tracking every single good or service, it looks at the total value of production, aggregate consumption, total investment, and so on. This allows economists to model the overall interactions between major parts of the economy.

---

Macroeconomic Decision Makers And Goals

Macroeconomic decisions are typically made by large entities like the national government or central bank (e.g., RBI). Their goals are generally related to public welfare and national objectives, such as achieving full employment, price stability, and economic growth, rather than individual profit maximization or personal satisfaction.

Some Basic Concepts Of Macroeconomics

This section introduces core concepts essential for understanding national income accounting, including the nature of production flow, different types of goods, and the distinction between stocks and flows.

---

Wealth And Production Flow

Economic wealth of a nation is not merely about possessing resources but about how these resources are combined through a production process to create a continuous flow of commodities (goods and services). This flow, generated by millions of enterprises, is what ultimately contributes to a country's income and wealth.

---

Commodities, Final Goods, Intermediate Goods

Commodities produced by firms are intended for sale. They can be broadly categorized based on their use:

• Intermediate Goods: These are goods used as inputs in the production of other goods and services. They are transformed or used up during the production process (e.g., cotton used to make yarn, flour used to make bread). Their value is included *within* the value of the final good.
• Final Goods: These are goods meant for final use and will not undergo further transformation by another producer. Once sold, they exit the active economic flow. Examples include clothing sold to a consumer or machinery bought by a firm. Counting only final goods avoids the problem of double counting.

The nature of the use, not the good itself, determines if it's final or intermediate (e.g., milk bought by a household is a final good; milk bought by a restaurant for making tea is an intermediate good).

---

Consumption Goods And Capital Goods

Final goods can be further classified:

• Consumption Goods (or Consumer Goods): Goods and services purchased by the ultimate consumers for direct satisfaction of needs and wants (e.g., food, clothing, recreation services). They are typically consumed relatively quickly.
• Capital Goods: Durable goods used in the production process over extended periods. They help produce other goods but are not transformed themselves (e.g., machinery, tools, buildings). They are considered final goods because they are not used up in a single production cycle.

---

Consumer Durables

Some goods purchased by consumers share a characteristic with capital goods: durability. Consumer durables (e.g., televisions, cars, home computers) have a relatively long lifespan and are not consumed immediately. Like capital goods, they experience wear and tear and may require maintenance or replacement over time.

Thus, the total final goods and services produced in an economy in a period consist of consumption goods (durable and non-durable) and capital goods.

---

Stocks And Flows

Economic variables can be classified based on whether they are measured at a specific point in time or over a period of time:

• Flow Variables: Measured over a period of time (e.g., income per year, production per month, consumption per quarter). They represent activity occurring over an interval.
• Stock Variables: Measured at a particular point in time (e.g., wealth as of today, capital stock of a firm at the end of the year, amount of money in a bank account now). They represent a quantity existing at a specific moment.

Changes in stock variables are considered flows (e.g., change in capital stock over a year is a flow).

An analogy: The water level in a tank at a specific moment is a stock. The rate at which water flows into the tank from the tap per minute is a flow.

---

Gross Investment, Net Investment, Depreciation

The part of the final output that comprises capital goods is called gross investment. This includes machinery, buildings, infrastructure, etc. However, some capital goods produced are used to replace or maintain the existing capital stock that has undergone wear and tear.

• Depreciation (Consumption of Fixed Capital): The annual allowance for the wear and tear of capital goods. It is the decrease in the value of capital stock due to normal use or passage of time. It is often calculated as the cost of the asset divided by its useful life ($D = \frac{\text{Cost of Asset}}{\text{Useful Life}}$). Depreciation is an accounting concept, representing the cost of using up capital.
• Net Investment (or New Capital Formation): This measures the true addition to the economy's capital stock. It is calculated by subtracting depreciation from gross investment.

  $ \text{Net Investment} = \text{Gross Investment} - \text{Depreciation} $

  Gross investment represents the total value of new capital goods produced, while net investment represents the actual increase in the capital stock available for future production.

Circular Flow Of Income And Methods Of Calculating National Income

This section explains the interconnectedness of economic activities in a simplified economy, illustrating how income flows between different sectors. It then introduces the three primary methods used to measure the total economic output or income of a nation, demonstrating their equivalence.

---

Simple Economy Model

A basic macroeconomic model involves interactions between households and firms. Households provide factors of production (labour, capital, land, entrepreneurship) to firms and receive income (wages, interest, rent, profit) in return. Firms use these factors to produce goods and services, which they sell back to households. In a simple model without government, external trade, or savings, households spend their entire income on goods and services produced by firms, and firms use all their revenue to pay factors of production.

---

The Circular Flow (Figure 2.1)

This model depicts income flowing continuously between households and firms. Payments from firms to households (factor payments) become income for households. Households then spend this income to buy goods and services from firms (consumption expenditure), which becomes revenue for firms. This flow moves in a circle, illustrating the interdependence of production, income, and expenditure in an economy.

The diagram shows two main loops:

• An inner loop representing the flow of real goods and services (factors of production from households to firms, goods/services from firms to households).
• An outer loop representing the flow of money (payments for factors from firms to households, payments for goods/services from households to firms).

---

Equivalence Of Three Methods

Because the same value of goods and services circulates in the economy (revenue received by firms equals factor payments made, which equals household expenditure), the aggregate value of economic activity can be measured at different points in the circular flow. This gives rise to three equivalent methods for calculating national income aggregates like GDP:

1. Product/Value Added Method: Measuring the value of goods and services produced.
2. Expenditure Method: Measuring the total spending on final goods and services.
3. Income Method: Measuring the total income earned by factors of production.

These three methods should yield the same aggregate value for the economy's output over a given period.

---

The Product Or Value Added Method (2.2.1)

This method calculates the aggregate value of final goods and services produced in the economy. To avoid double counting, it focuses on the value added by each firm in the production process.

Value Added is the contribution made by a firm to the value of the final product. It is calculated as:

$ \text{Value Added} = \text{Value of Output Produced by the Firm} - \text{Value of Intermediate Goods Used} $

Summing the value added of all firms in the economy gives the Gross Value Added (GVA). Summing the GVA of all firms provides the Gross Domestic Product (GDP).

$ \text{GDP} \equiv \sum \text{GVA}_i $ (where $i$ represents each firm)

If depreciation is deducted from Gross Value Added, we get Net Value Added (NVA), which represents the value added after accounting for the wear and tear of capital.

$ \text{Net Value Added} = \text{Gross Value Added} - \text{Depreciation} $

Stocks of unsold finished goods, semi-finished goods, or raw materials held by a firm from one period to the next are called inventories. Change in inventories is considered a flow variable and is treated as a form of investment.

$ \text{Change in Inventories} \equiv \text{Production during the period} - \text{Sales during the period} $

Gross Value Added can also be expressed considering sales and change in inventories:

$ \text{GVA}_i \equiv \text{Value of Sales by Firm } i + \text{Value of Change in Inventories of Firm } i - \text{Value of Intermediate Goods Used by Firm } i $

Investment includes addition to inventories (change in inventories), fixed business investment (addition to machinery, buildings), and residential investment (addition to housing). Change in inventories can be planned (intentional change in stock level) or unplanned (due to unexpected sales fluctuations).

Answer:

Answer:

---

Expenditure Method (2.2.2)

This method calculates GDP by summing up the total spending on final goods and services within the domestic economy during a period. Expenditure on intermediate goods is excluded.

The major components of final expenditure are:

• Consumption Expenditure (C): Spending by households on final consumer goods and services.
• Investment Expenditure (I): Spending by firms on capital goods (machinery, buildings) and changes in inventories (both planned and unplanned). Note: This includes investment in domestic capital goods.
• Government Expenditure (G): Spending by the government on final goods and services (both consumption and investment type).
• Net Exports (X - M): Spending by foreigners on domestic goods (Exports, X) minus spending by domestic residents on foreign goods (Imports, M). Exports add to domestic demand, while imports subtract from domestic expenditure on domestically produced goods.

GDP is the sum of these final expenditures on domestically produced goods and services:

$ \text{GDP} \equiv \text{C} + \text{I} + \text{G} + (\text{X} - \text{M}) $

Where C, I, and G represent total consumption, investment, and government spending, and (X-M) adjusts for international trade to only count expenditure on goods produced within the country.

---

Income Method (2.2.3)

This method calculates GDP by summing up the total income earned by all factors of production within the domestic economy during a period. Since the value created in production is distributed as income to the factors that contributed to it, the sum of these factor incomes equals the value of output.

The main components of factor income are:

• Wages and Salaries (W): Income earned by labour.
• Profits (P): Income earned by entrepreneurs/owners.
• Interest (In): Income earned by owners of capital.
• Rent (R): Income earned by owners of land/natural resources.

GDP is the sum of these factor incomes generated within the domestic territory:

$ \text{GDP} \equiv \text{W} + \text{P} + \text{In} + \text{R} $

(Note: In practice, this may also include mixed income of self-employed individuals).

Combining the three methods gives the fundamental identity:

$ \text{GDP} \equiv \sum \text{GVA}_i \equiv \text{C} + \text{I} + \text{G} + (\text{X} - \text{M}) \equiv \text{W} + \text{P} + \text{In} + \text{R} $

Answer:

	Farmer	Baker
Sales	100	200
Intermediate consumption	0	50
Value added	100	150

	Firm A	Firm B
Wages	20	60
Profits	30	90

Note on Example Consistency: While the principle states all three methods yield the same result, the numerical example provided in the source text shows inconsistencies between the initial calculation in 2.2.1 (resulting in 250) and the values presented in Tables 2.2, 2.3, and the subsequent calculations in 2.2.1 (Value Added sum is 200 in Table 2.2) and 2.2.3 (Income sum is 200). The Expenditure Method calculation in 2.2.2 also results in 250 based on the initial description. I have presented the examples using the numbers as they appear in the source text's specific example calculations, which show GDP=200 for VA and Income methods (based on the table numbers) and GDP=250 for the Expenditure method (based on the narrative description). The prompt asks me to provide the example as is. I will stick to the text's presentation.

---

Factor Cost, Basic Prices And Market Prices (2.2.4)

GDP and other aggregates can be valued at different price concepts, distinguished by how taxes and subsidies are included:

• Factor Cost (FC): Reflects the income earned by the factors of production. It excludes all taxes and includes all subsidies. This was historically a common measure in India.
• Market Prices (MP): Reflects the price paid by the final buyer in the market. It includes all indirect taxes (net of subsidies) that affect the final price of goods and services.

  $ \text{GDP}_\text{MP} = \text{GDP}_\text{FC} + \text{Indirect Taxes} - \text{Subsidies} = \text{GDP}_\text{FC} + \text{Net Indirect Taxes} $

  $ \text{Net Indirect Taxes} = \text{Indirect Taxes} - \text{Subsidies} $

• Basic Prices (BP): An intermediate valuation concept introduced more recently. It includes production taxes (less production subsidies) but excludes product taxes (less product subsidies).
  • Production Taxes/Subsidies: Paid/received regardless of the volume of production (e.g., land revenue, stamp duty).
  • Product Taxes/Subsidies: Paid/received per unit of product (e.g., excise duty, sales tax, service tax, export/import duties).

  $ \text{GVA}_\text{BP} = \text{GVA}_\text{FC} + \text{Net Production Taxes} $

  $ \text{GVA}_\text{MP} = \text{GVA}_\text{BP} + \text{Net Product Taxes} $

  Since GDP is the sum of GVA for all firms in the economy, at the aggregate level:

  $ \text{GDP}_\text{MP} = \sum \text{GVA}_\text{MP} = \sum (\text{GVA}_\text{BP} + \text{Net Product Taxes}_i) = \sum \text{GVA}_\text{BP} + \sum \text{Net Product Taxes}_i $

  In India, the Central Statistics Office (CSO) now highlights GVA at basic prices and GDP at market prices (simply called GDP).

Some Macroeconomic Identities

GDP is one of several aggregate income measures. This section defines other important macroeconomic aggregates derived from GDP, accounting for factors like income from abroad, depreciation, taxes, and transfers, leading to concepts like National Income, Personal Income, and Disposable Income.

---

Gross National Product (GNP)

GDP measures the output produced within the domestic territory of a country, regardless of who owns the factors of production (domestic or foreign entities). Gross National Product (GNP), on the other hand, measures the output produced by the normal residents of a country, regardless of where they are located (domestic or abroad).

The difference between GDP and GNP is Net Factor Income from Abroad (NFIA).

$ \text{NFIA} = \text{Factor income earned by domestic residents abroad} - \text{Factor income earned by foreign residents domestically} $

$ \text{GNP} \equiv \text{GDP} + \text{NFIA} $

If NFIA is positive, GNP is greater than GDP, meaning domestic residents abroad earn more than foreign residents domestically. If NFIA is negative, GDP is greater than GNP.

---

Net National Product (NNP)

GNP includes the value of production needed to replace depreciated capital stock. To find the net addition to wealth or income available for consumption or genuine saving, we subtract depreciation from GNP. This gives us Net National Product (NNP).

$ \text{NNP} \equiv \text{GNP} - \text{Depreciation} $

NNP represents the net value of goods and services produced by normal residents after accounting for the wearing out of capital. Like GDP and GNP, NNP can be calculated at Market Prices or Factor Cost/Basic Prices.

---

National Income (NI)

National Income (NI) is equivalent to Net National Product at Factor Cost (NNP$_{FC}$). It represents the total income earned by the factors of production owned by the normal residents of a country.

To move from NNP at Market Prices to NNP at Factor Cost (National Income), we subtract net indirect taxes (Indirect taxes - Subsidies), as these represent payments to the government, not factor income.

$ \text{NI} \equiv \text{NNP}_\text{FC} \equiv \text{NNP}_\text{MP} - (\text{Indirect Taxes} - \text{Subsidies}) \equiv \text{NNP}_\text{MP} - \text{Net Indirect Taxes} $

National Income is a key measure representing the aggregate income available to the factors supplying services.

---

Personal Income (PI)

National Income (NI) represents the total income generated, but not all of it is actually received by households. Some income is retained by firms or paid as taxes before reaching households. Personal Income (PI) measures the income actually received by households.

To derive PI from NI, adjustments are made:

• Subtract Undistributed Profits (UP) of firms (retained earnings).
• Subtract Corporate Tax (CT) paid by firms.
• Subtract Net Interest Payments made by Households (NIH) (interest paid by households minus interest received by households).
• Add Transfer Payments (TrH) received by households from the government and firms (e.g., pensions, scholarships, unemployment benefits).

$ \text{PI} \equiv \text{NI} - \text{UP} - \text{CT} - \text{NIH} + \text{TrH} $

(Note: The text's formula structure is $\text{PI} \equiv \text{NI} - \text{UP} - \text{Net interest payments made by households} - \text{Corporate tax} + \text{Transfer payments to the households from the government and firms}$. This is equivalent to the structure above using symbols, where NIH is net interest paid *by* households.)

---

Personal Disposable Income (PDI)

Even Personal Income is not entirely available for households to spend or save as they wish. Households must pay personal taxes and other non-tax payments to the government. Personal Disposable Income (PDI) is the income households have left after paying personal taxes and non-tax payments, which they can freely dispose of (either consume or save).

$ \text{PDI} \equiv \text{PI} - \text{Personal Tax Payments (PTP)} - \text{Non-tax Payments (NP)} $

PDI represents the income available for households' final consumption expenditure and saving.

---

National Disposable Income And Private Income

Besides the core identities, other aggregates are used:

• National Disposable Income: Represents the maximum amount of goods and services the domestic economy has control over. It is calculated as NNP at market prices plus net current transfers from the rest of the world (e.g., gifts, aid).

  $ \text{National Disposable Income} = \text{NNP}_\text{MP} + \text{Net current transfers from Rest of the World} $

• Private Income: A concept often used in India, it represents the income accruing to the private sector (households and private firms). It includes factor income earned domestically by the private sector, NFIA, interest on national debt, and transfers from the government and the rest of the world.

  $ \text{Private Income} = \text{NDP}_\text{FC} \text{ accruing to private sector} + \text{NFIA} + \text{Net interest on National Debt} + \text{Current transfers from Govt.} + \text{Other net transfers from RoW} $

  ($\text{NDP}_\text{FC} \text{ accruing to private sector} = \text{NDP}_\text{FC} - \text{Income from domestic product accruing to government administration}$)

  Figure 2.3 provides a diagrammatic representation of the relationships between these aggregates.

S.No.	Item	Definition/Calculation
1.	Gross Domestic Product at Market Prices (GDP$_{MP}$)	Market value of all final goods and services produced within a domestic territory in a year. Includes production by residents and non-residents. $\text{GDP}_{MP} = \text{C} + \text{I} + \text{G} + \text{X} - \text{M}$
2.	GDP at Factor Cost (GDP$_{FC}$)	GDP at market prices minus net product taxes. Measures money value of output produced by firms within domestic boundaries. $\text{GDP}_{FC} = \text{GDP}_{MP} - \text{Net Product Taxes}$
3.	Net Domestic Product at Market Prices (NDP$_{MP}$)	GDP at market prices minus depreciation. Measures output after accounting for capital wear and tear within the domestic territory. $\text{NDP}_{MP} = \text{GDP}_{MP} - \text{Depreciation}$
4.	NDP at Factor Cost (NDP$_{FC}$)	Income earned by factors of production within the domestic territory. $\text{NDP}_{FC} = \text{NDP}_{MP} - \text{Net Product Taxes}$ (Assuming Net Production Taxes are zero or already adjusted) OR $\text{NDP}_{FC} = \text{NDP}_{MP} - \text{Net Product Taxes} - \text{Net Production Taxes}$ (Based on table text which seems to imply Net Product Taxes + Net Production Taxes need to be subtracted from NDP MP)
5.	Gross National Product at Market Prices (GNP$_{MP}$)	Value of final goods and services produced by normal residents (domestic or abroad), measured at market prices. $\text{GNP}_{MP} = \text{GDP}_{MP} + \text{NFIA}$
6.	GNP at Factor Cost (GNP$_{FC}$)	Value of output received by factors of production belonging to a country's normal residents. $\text{GNP}_{FC} = \text{GNP}_{MP} - \text{Net Product Taxes} - \text{Net Production Taxes}$ (Based on table text)
7.	Net National Product at Market Prices (NNP$_{MP}$)	GNP at market prices minus depreciation. Measures output by normal residents after accounting for capital wear and tear. $\text{NNP}_{MP} = \text{GNP}_{MP} - \text{Depreciation}$ OR $\text{NNP}_{MP} = \text{NDP}_{MP} + \text{NFIA}$
8.	NNP at Factor Cost (NNP$_{FC}$) or National Income (NI)	Sum of income earned by all factors of production belonging to a country's normal residents. $\text{NI} \equiv \text{NNP}_{FC} \equiv \text{NNP}_{MP} - \text{Net Product Taxes} - \text{Net Production Taxes}$ (Based on table text) OR $\text{NI} \equiv \text{NDP}_{FC} + \text{NFIA}$
9.	GVA at Market Prices	Same as GDP at Market Prices.
10.	GVA at basic prices	GVA at market prices minus net product taxes. $\text{GVA}_\text{BP} = \text{GVA}_\text{MP} - \text{Net Product Taxes}$
11.	GVA at factor cost	GVA at basic prices minus net production taxes. $\text{GVA}_\text{FC} = \text{GVA}_\text{BP} - \text{Net Production Taxes}$

Nominal And Real Gdp

When comparing GDP over time or between countries, changes in prices can distort the picture of actual production changes. This section explains how to distinguish between GDP measured at current prices (Nominal GDP) and GDP measured at constant prices (Real GDP), and introduces price indices used for this adjustment.

---

Comparing Gdps With Changing Prices

If GDP figures change from one year to the next, it could be due to a change in the actual volume of goods and services produced, or simply a change in their prices, or a combination of both. To accurately compare the volume of production over time, the effect of price changes needs to be removed.

---

Real Gdp Versus Nominal Gdp

• Nominal GDP: The value of goods and services produced in an economy calculated using the current prices prevailing in that specific year. It reflects both changes in quantity and changes in price.
• Real GDP: The value of goods and services produced in an economy calculated using constant prices from a chosen base year. It reflects only changes in the volume of production, as the prices are held fixed.

Real GDP is a better indicator for comparing economic output over time, as it shows actual growth in production volume.

Answer:

---

Gdp Deflator

The GDP deflator is a price index that measures the average level of prices of all new, domestically produced, final goods and services in an economy. It is calculated as the ratio of Nominal GDP to Real GDP, often expressed as a percentage.

$ \text{GDP Deflator} = \frac{\text{Nominal GDP}}{\text{Real GDP}} \times 100 $

It reflects the change in the price level between the base year (used for real GDP) and the current year.

Answer:

---

Consumer Price Index (Cpi)

The Consumer Price Index (CPI) is another widely used price index. It measures the average change over time in the prices paid by urban consumers for a fixed basket of consumer goods and services.

CPI is calculated by taking the price changes for each item in the predetermined basket of goods and averaging them according to their weights (reflecting consumer spending patterns). The cost of the fixed basket in the current year is compared to the cost of the same basket in the base year.

$ \text{CPI} = \frac{\text{Cost of Fixed Basket in Current Year}}{\text{Cost of Fixed Basket in Base Year}} \times 100 $

Answer:

---

Wholesale Price Index (Wpi)

The Wholesale Price Index (WPI) measures the average change in the prices of goods at the wholesale level, i.e., goods traded in bulk between businesses. It includes prices of raw materials, intermediate goods, and finished goods. In some countries, it is called the Producer Price Index (PPI).

WPI differs from CPI as it tracks prices at an earlier stage of the distribution chain and includes goods not directly purchased by consumers.

---

Differences Between Cpi And Gdp Deflator

CPI and GDP deflator are both price indices but differ in scope and construction:

1. Scope of Goods: GDP deflator includes prices of all final goods and services produced domestically. CPI includes prices of a fixed basket of goods and services purchased by representative consumers (including imported goods).
2. Imported Goods: CPI includes prices of imported goods consumed by households. GDP deflator only includes prices of domestically produced goods, so it excludes imports.
3. Weights: CPI uses fixed weights based on the typical consumer basket in the base year. GDP deflator uses weights that change each year, reflecting the current year's production proportions of different goods and services.

Gdp And Welfare

While GDP is a key indicator of economic activity, it is not a perfect measure of the overall well-being or welfare of a country's population. This section discusses reasons why higher GDP does not always translate directly to increased welfare.

---

Limitations Of Gdp As A Welfare Index

Higher income or output generally allows people to consume more goods and services, potentially increasing their material well-being. However, using GDP as a sole measure of welfare has significant limitations.

---

Distribution Of Gdp

A rising GDP does not guarantee improved welfare for everyone. If the increase in GDP is concentrated among a small percentage of the population while the majority see their incomes stagnate or fall, overall societal welfare might not improve or could even decline. GDP is an aggregate measure that doesn't inherently reflect how evenly income or output is distributed among the population.

Answer:

---

Non-Monetary Exchanges

Many economic activities and exchanges, particularly in informal sectors or within households (like domestic work by women), are not conducted through monetary transactions. These non-monetary exchanges (e.g., barter) are often not captured in official GDP statistics, leading to an underestimation of the actual economic activity and welfare generated.

---

Externalities

Externalities are side effects of economic activities that affect third parties who are not directly involved in the transaction, and for which no payment is made or received. They are not reflected in market prices or GDP calculations.

• Negative Externalities: Harmful effects (e.g., pollution from a factory harming a river and fishermen). GDP counts the value of the factory's output but doesn't subtract the cost of the environmental damage or loss of livelihood caused. Thus, GDP overestimates welfare in the presence of negative externalities.
• Positive Externalities: Beneficial effects (e.g., a firm's investment in R&D that creates knowledge benefiting other firms). GDP counts the R&D expenditure but may not fully capture the wider societal benefit. Thus, GDP may underestimate welfare in the presence of positive externalities.

Because externalities are not accounted for, GDP is an incomplete measure of the true social costs and benefits of production, and thus an imperfect indicator of welfare.