Investment Returns and Growth Rate Metrics

Calculation of Returns (Absolute Return, Percentage Return)

Measuring Investment Performance: Basic Methods

Evaluating how an investment has performed over time is essential for making informed financial decisions. The most fundamental ways to quantify investment performance are by calculating the absolute return and the percentage return.

Absolute Return

• Definition: The absolute return represents the total gain or loss on an investment in monetary terms over a specific period. It's the straightforward difference between the investment's value at the end of the period and its value at the beginning of the period.

• Formula:

  $\mathbf{Absolute\$ Return = Final\$ Value - Initial\$ Value}$

  Where:

  • Final Value (or Ending Value) is the value of the investment at the measurement date.
  • Initial Value (or Beginning Value) is the value of the investment at the starting date.

  If the investment generated income during the period (like dividends from stocks or interest from bonds), this income should be added to the investment's final market value to get the total Final Value for calculating the return.

• Interpretation:

  • A positive Absolute Return signifies a profit or gain in terms of rupees (or the relevant currency) over the investment period.
  • A negative Absolute Return indicates a monetary loss.
  • An Absolute Return of zero means the investment's monetary value did not change.

  It directly tells you the total number of rupees gained or lost.

• Limitation: While simple to calculate, the absolute return does not provide a complete picture. Its main drawback is that it doesn't take into account the size of the initial investment or the length of time over which the return was earned. For example, an absolute return of $\textsf{₹}\$ 10,000$ is much better if the initial investment was $\textsf{₹}\$ 50,000$ than if it was $\textsf{₹}\$ 10,00,000$. Similarly, $\textsf{₹}\$ 10,000$ earned in one month is better than in five years. This limitation makes comparing different investments using only absolute return difficult and often misleading.

Percentage Return (or Simple Return or Holding Period Return)

• Definition: The percentage return expresses the absolute return as a proportion of the initial investment, presented as a percentage. This metric provides a relative measure of performance, making it more useful than absolute return for comparing investments of different sizes.

• Formula:

  $\mathbf{Percentage\$ Return (\%) = \frac{Final\$ Value - Initial\$ Value}{Initial\$ Value} \times 100}$

  Alternatively, using the already calculated absolute return:

  $\mathbf{Percentage\$ Return (\%) = \frac{Absolute\$ Return}{Initial\$ Value} \times 100}$

  Where:

  • Final Value and Initial Value are as defined for absolute return.
  • The result is multiplied by 100 to convert the decimal or fractional return into a percentage.

• Interpretation:

  • A positive percentage return indicates a gain relative to the initial investment amount.
  • A negative percentage return indicates a loss relative to the initial investment amount.
  • A percentage return of 25% means the investment's value increased by an amount equal to 25% of its starting value over the period.

  This metric allows for a standardized comparison of the performance of investments with different initial capital amounts.

• Limitation: While the percentage return addresses the issue of initial investment size, it still does not account for the time period over which the return was achieved. This metric is often called the "Holding Period Return" because it represents the total return earned over the entire time the investment was held, regardless of how long that period was. Comparing a 30% return earned over 2 years with a 30% return earned over 5 years using just the percentage return is problematic. It also doesn't reflect how the return would compound over multiple periods (e.g., annual compounding), making it less suitable for comparing investments with different periodic payout structures or for understanding annualized growth rates over multi-year horizons.

Worked Example

Answer:

Investment Returns and Growth Rate Metrics: Nominal Rate of Return

Definition of Nominal Rate of Return

The Nominal Rate of Return is the stated, or quoted, rate of return on an investment or a loan, expressed in simple percentage terms per period (usually annually). It represents the percentage increase in the amount of money before taking into account factors like inflation or the frequency of compounding within the period for which the rate is quoted.

• It is the rate that you typically see advertised for fixed deposits, bonds (coupon rate), or loan products (e.g., "Invest at 7% p.a.", "Loan available at 10% p.a.").
• It reflects the growth of the principal in terms of the number of currency units (e.g., how many more Rupees you have) but does not account for changes in the purchasing power of that currency due to inflation.
• If interest is compounded more frequently than the period for which the nominal rate is stated (e.g., a nominal annual rate compounded monthly), the nominal rate will be different from the effective annual rate, which reflects the true compounded annual growth.

Nominal Rate vs. Real Rate of Return

One of the key distinctions involving the nominal rate is its difference from the Real Rate of Return. While the nominal rate measures the increase in the *amount* of money, the real rate measures the increase in the *purchasing power* of money after accounting for inflation.

The approximate relationship between the nominal rate, real rate, and inflation rate is given by:

$Real\$ Rate\$ of\$ Return \approx Nominal\$ Rate\$ of\$ Return - Inflation\$ Rate$

For example, if you invest at a nominal rate of 8% per annum, but the inflation rate during that year is 5%, your purchasing power has effectively only increased by approximately $8\% - 5\% = 3\%$.

The more precise relationship, derived using compounding principles, is:

$(1 + Real\$ Rate) = \frac{1 + Nominal\$ Rate}{1 + Inflation\$ Rate}$

From this, the Real Rate can be calculated as:

$Real\$ Rate = \frac{1 + Nominal\$ Rate}{1 + Inflation\$ Rate} - 1$

In the previous example with an 8% nominal rate and 5% inflation: $Real\$ Rate = \frac{1.08}{1.05} - 1 \approx 1.02857 - 1 = 0.02857 = 2.857\%$. The approximation ($3\%$) is close but less precise. In periods of high inflation, a seemingly attractive nominal rate might still result in a very low or even negative real rate of return, meaning the investment is losing purchasing power.

Nominal Rate vs. Effective Annual Rate (EAR)

Another crucial distinction is between the nominal annual rate and the Effective Annual Rate (EAR). As discussed previously, if a nominal annual rate is compounded more than once a year (e.g., semi-annually, quarterly, monthly), the actual rate of return earned over a full year will be higher than the nominal rate due to the effect of interest earning interest (compounding) within the year.

The EAR is the single annual rate that would produce the same accumulated amount as the nominal rate compounded $m$ times per year over a one-year period. The relationship is:

$EAR = \left(1 + \frac{r}{m}\right)^{m} - 1$

Where $r$ is the nominal annual rate (as a decimal) and $m$ is the number of compounding periods per year. For instance, a nominal annual rate of 10% compounded quarterly ($r=0.10, m=4$) results in an EAR of $\left(1 + \frac{0.10}{4}\right)^{4} - 1 = (1.025)^4 - 1 \approx 1.10381 - 1 = 0.10381$, or 10.381%. The nominal rate is 10%, but the effective annual rate is 10.381%.

Conclusion

The nominal rate of return is the most straightforward and commonly quoted rate. However, for accurate financial analysis, comparison between investments with different compounding frequencies, or assessing the true growth in purchasing power, it is essential to understand the limitations of the nominal rate and consider the Effective Annual Rate (EAR) and the Real Rate of Return.

Investment Returns and Growth Rate Metrics: Compound Annual Growth Rate (CAGR): Definition and Calculation

Definition of Compound Annual Growth Rate (CAGR)

The Compound Annual Growth Rate (CAGR) is a key metric used to calculate the average annual growth rate of an investment or any variable over a period of time greater than one year. It represents the constant annual growth rate that, if applied over the specified number of years with compounding, would result in the observed total growth from the beginning value to the ending value. CAGR effectively smooths out the year-to-year fluctuations and volatility, providing a single, representative average annual rate of growth.

CAGR is not an arithmetic mean (simple average) of annual returns, but rather a geometric mean, which is more appropriate for measuring growth over multiple periods with compounding.

Purpose and Applications

CAGR is a widely used metric in financial analysis for several purposes:

• Comparing Investment Performance: CAGR allows for a standardized comparison of the performance of different investments, even if they have different holding periods or different patterns of growth over those periods.

• Analyzing Business Metrics: It is used to measure and compare the growth rate of various business indicators, such as sales revenue, profitability, market share, or customer base, over multiple fiscal years.

• Smoothing Volatility: By providing a single average rate, CAGR masks the volatility experienced year-to-year, which can be helpful for long-term trend analysis.

• Goal Setting and Forecasting: While past performance is not indicative of future results, calculated CAGRs can be used as a basis for setting growth targets or making projections for future performance, assuming similar average growth conditions persist.

Formula Derivation

The formula for CAGR is derived directly from the fundamental compound interest formula, which models how an initial sum grows over time with compounding interest. The compound interest formula is:

$FV = PV (1 + i)^n$

Where:

• $FV$ = Future Value (the value at the end of the period).
• $PV$ = Present Value (the value at the beginning of the period).
• $i$ = The interest rate per period (as a decimal).
• $n$ = The number of periods.

In the context of CAGR, we are interested in the average annual growth rate. We define:

• Ending Value = $FV$
• Beginning Value = $PV$
• Number of Years = $n$
• Compound Annual Growth Rate = $CAGR$ (This is the constant annual rate, replacing $i$).

Substituting these terms into the compound interest formula, assuming annual compounding for the purpose of finding an *annual* rate:

Using our symbols:

Our objective is to find the formula for CAGR. We need to isolate CAGR on one side of the equation. We do this with algebraic manipulations:

1. Divide both sides of the equation by the Beginning Value (PV):

This simplifies to:

$\frac{FV}{PV} = (1 + CAGR)^n$

2. To eliminate the exponent $n$ from the right side and isolate $(1 + CAGR)$, raise both sides of the equation to the power of $\frac{1}{n}$ (which is the $n$-th root):

This simplifies to:

$\left( \frac{FV}{PV} \right)^{1/n} = 1 + CAGR$

3. Finally, subtract 1 from both sides of the equation to get the formula for CAGR:

Formula for Compound Annual Growth Rate (CAGR)

The formula to calculate the Compound Annual Growth Rate (CAGR) is:

$\mathbf{CAGR = \left( \frac{\text{Ending Value}}{\text{Beginning Value}} \right)^{1/n} - 1}$

Where:

• Ending Value (FV) = The value of the investment, sales figure, or any other metric at the end of the specified period.
• Beginning Value (PV) = The value of the investment or metric at the start of the specified period.
• n = The number of years in the specified period. This is calculated as the difference between the end year and the beginning year. If the period is given in other units (like months), it must be converted to years for this formula (e.g., 30 months = 30/12 = 2.5 years).

The result of this formula is the CAGR expressed as a decimal. To express it as a percentage, multiply the decimal value by 100.

$\mathbf{CAGR (\%) = \left[ \left( \frac{\text{Ending Value}}{\text{Beginning Value}} \right)^{1/n} - 1 \right] \times 100}$

Worked Example

Answer:

Applications of CAGR in Investment Analysis

Utility of CAGR in Evaluating Investments

The Compound Annual Growth Rate (CAGR) is a widely adopted metric in the field of investment analysis and finance due to its ability to provide a standardized and smoothed measure of growth over multiple periods. While simple percentage return (holding period return) is useful for a single period, CAGR extends this concept to multi-year horizons, accounting for the power of compounding.

Here are some key applications of CAGR:

• Performance Comparison Across Different Investments: One of the most significant uses of CAGR is to compare the average annual performance of various investment options (such as stocks, mutual funds, fixed deposits, or even different portfolios), different fund managers, or market indices. CAGR provides a common yardstick (an annualized rate) regardless of the investment type, initial investment amount, or the specific period over which the returns were generated. This allows for an "apples-to-apples" comparison of average growth rates.

• Analyzing and Benchmarking Historical Returns: Financial reports and investment factsheets frequently present historical CAGRs for periods like 3 years, 5 years, 10 years, etc. This gives investors a concise overview of the average growth achieved over these standard timeframes. Investors can also compare the CAGR of their own portfolio against the CAGR of relevant market benchmarks (like Nifty or Sensex) over the same period to assess relative performance.

• Smoothing Out Year-to-Year Volatility: Real-world investment returns are rarely constant; they fluctuate from year to year due to market conditions. While year-on-year returns are important, CAGR provides a single, constant average rate that captures the overall growth trend over the entire period, effectively smoothing out the peaks and troughs of annual returns. This can give a clearer picture of the long-term growth trajectory.

• Goal Setting and Long-Term Projections (with caution): Although historical performance is not a guarantee of future results, calculated CAGRs can sometimes be used as a basis for setting future growth targets or making rough long-term financial projections. For example, if a mutual fund has historically delivered a CAGR of 15%, an investor might cautiously use this as an assumption for projecting the future value of their investments, while acknowledging the inherent uncertainty.

• Evaluating Growth of Non-Investment Metrics: Beyond financial investments, CAGR is also applied in business analysis to measure the average growth rate of metrics like sales revenue, profitability, number of customers, or market share over multiple periods.

In summary, CAGR is a powerful tool for summarizing and comparing growth over time by providing a single, representative annualized rate that accounts for compounding.

Limitations of CAGR

While useful, it is important to be aware of CAGR's limitations to avoid misinterpreting investment performance:

• Ignores Path and Volatility: CAGR only considers the beginning and ending values and the number of years. It tells you nothing about the year-to-year fluctuations or the volatility experienced during the period. Two investments could have the exact same CAGR, but one might have had a smooth upward trend while the other experienced wild swings and significant drawdowns. CAGR does not capture this risk aspect.

• Assumes Compounding/Reinvestment: The calculation inherently assumes that all returns are reinvested (compounded) at the end of each period at the calculated CAGR rate. This might not reflect reality if an investor withdrew income or did not reinvest gains.

• Sensitivity to Endpoints: The calculated CAGR can be heavily influenced by the choice of the beginning and ending dates, especially if these dates correspond to market peaks or troughs. A change of just a few months in the start or end date can significantly alter the calculated CAGR.

• Not Representative of Individual Period Returns: The calculated CAGR is an average. The actual return in any single year within the period could be much higher or lower than the CAGR.

• Does Not Handle Intermediate Cash Flows Easily: The basic CAGR formula is best suited for a single lump-sum investment that grows over time. It is not designed to easily incorporate investments or withdrawals made during the period. For investments with intermediate cash flows, other metrics like the Money-Weighted Rate of Return (MWRR) or Time-Weighted Rate of Return (TWRR) are more appropriate.

Despite these limitations, CAGR remains a widely used and valuable metric when its interpretation is done with an understanding of what it does and does not represent.

Problems based on Investment Returns and Growth Rates

This section provides examples applying the concepts and formulas for calculating investment returns, including absolute return, percentage return (holding period return), and Compound Annual Growth Rate (CAGR). These problems often require identifying the initial value, final value, and the relevant time period, and then applying the appropriate formula.

Worked Examples

Answer:

Answer:

Answer:

Answer: